Skip to content

From Calving Ease to Dystocia: Understanding Calving Difficulty

Table of content
All posts

Calving difficulty, also known as calving ease, plays a pivotal role in the success of both dairy and beef cattle operations. This term describes the ease or struggle a cow experiences while giving birth to a calf. The calving process can be challenging, and the degree of difficulty significantly impacts the health and survival of both the cow and the calf.

Why is calving difficulty data important?

Several factors contribute to calving difficulty, including the size and shape of the calf, the size and condition of the dam, and the calf's positioning during birth. Breeds and individual genetics also play a role, as certain breeds or individual animals may be more prone to difficult births.

Calving ease also influences breeding decisions. Selecting bulls likely to sire calves that heifers can birth with ease—especially for first-calf heifers—or understanding a specific dam's history, will minimize risk to both the heifer and the dam.

Monitoring and managing calving ease are crucial for many reasons. Difficult births can result in injury or death for the calf or the cow. They can also lead to increased veterinary costs, lower milk production, reduced fertility, and longer intervals before the cow is ready to breed again. Consequently, farmers often take steps to manage calving ease, like selecting appropriate sires, managing the nutrition and condition of pregnant cows, and preparing to assist with difficult births if necessary.

What are the benefits of tracking calving difficulty?

Recording calving ease offers several benefits to dairy farmers. Here are some reasons why it's beneficial:

  1. Health Monitoring: Regularly recording calving ease allows farmers to track the health and well-being of cows and calves. It provides data that can help identify potential health issues early, enabling prompt medical intervention if necessary.
  2. Breeding Decisions: Recording calving ease can inform future breeding decisions. For instance, if a particular cow consistently has difficult births, a farmer might choose to breed her with a bull known for siring smaller calves or choose to cull her from the breeding herd. Similarly, if calves sired by a particular bull often cause calving difficulty, the farmer might reconsider using that bull in the future.
  3. Economic Impact: Difficult births can result in significant veterinary costs, and may also lead to decreased milk production or fertility problems in the dam. By recording and monitoring calving ease, farmers can identify and manage these risks, potentially saving money in the long term.
  4. Genetic Selection and Improvement: Data on calving ease can contribute to broader efforts to improve the genetics of the herd. By identifying animals that tend to have easy or difficult births, farmers can make informed decisions about which animals to keep for breeding and which to cull, thereby gradually improving the overall genetics of the herd.
  5. Farm Management: Data on calving ease can help farmers better manage their herds. For example, it can help them anticipate which animals are likely to need assistance during calving, allowing them to allocate their resources more effectively.
  6. Data Analysis and Benchmarking: By recording calving ease, farmers can analyze trends over time, compare their results to benchmarks, and assess the impact of changes in their management practices.

In short, recording calving ease provides valuable data that helps dairy farmers maintain their herds' health, make informed breeding decisions, manage their operations more effectively, and contribute to genetic improvement efforts.

Calving Ease vs. Dystocia Data

Calving ease and dystocia are both measures used to evaluate the difficulty of a calf's birth, but they represent different levels of data detail. Calving ease is a simpler measure, typically recorded on a scale from 1 to 5:

  1. No difficulty, no assistance needed
  2. Slight difficulty, some assistance given
  3. Moderate difficulty, considerable assistance given
  4. Severe difficulty, mechanical assistance required
  5. Cesarean section or other surgery needed

In contrast, complete dystocia data provides a more detailed picture of the birthing process. Dystocia refers to difficult or abnormal labor, and recording complete dystocia data can involve noting a wide range of factors, including:

  • The duration of labor
  • The position and presentation of the calf (e.g., whether it was positioned normally or abnormally in the birth canal)
  • The size of the calf relative to the dam
  • Any injuries sustained by the dam or the calf during birth
  • Any interventions performed (e.g., manual assistance, use of obstetric chains, use of a calf jack, veterinary interventions)
  • Any post-calving complications for the dam or calf

By recording only calving ease, you get a broad overview of how easy or difficult each birth was, which can be useful for identifying general trends and making breeding decisions. However, by recording the complete dystocia data, you get a much richer set of information that can help you understand why certain births were difficult and how you might be able to prevent similar difficulties in the future. You can also use this data to more closely monitor the health of your cows and calves and provide more targeted care as needed.

So, while recording calving ease is less time-consuming and may be sufficient for many purposes, recording complete dystocia data can provide a greater level of insight into the health and well-being of your herd.

Recording Calving Ease and Dystocia in DHI-Plus

DHI-Plus software offers a comprehensive and intuitive way to record calving difficulty data. With an easy-to-use interface, the software allows for both one-digit calving ease ratings and a more detailed four-digit dystocia assessment. The single-digit rating provides a quick overview of the birthing process, capturing essential data for a farmer's immediate evaluation. For a deeper dive into calving outcomes, the four-digit rating system comes into play, recording calving difficulty, calf size, calf livability, and calf condition separately. This provides a granular view of each birth, allowing for nuanced analysis and efficient decision-making.

Reports in DHI-Plus

With the Event Analysis tool, you can create a calving difficulty report to view your calving results over time. By recording and tracking these factors, you'll be ready to identify trends, make informed breeding decisions, and improve overall herd health.

Sharing your data with the CDCB

The Council on Dairy Cattle Breeding (CDCB) in the United States, as well as similar organizations in other countries, collect and analyze data from dairy farmers to improve the overall quality of the industry. Sharing calf dystocia data with these organizations can have several benefits:

  1. Genetic improvement: Dystocia data can be used to improve breeding programs by identifying bulls whose offspring have lower rates of dystocia. This can lead to the development of herds with easier, less risky births.
  2. Industry benchmarks: Sharing this data allows the CDCB to create industry-wide benchmarks and standards. This can help individual farmers gauge their herd's performance relative to the industry and identify areas for improvement.
  3. Research and development: This data is crucial for research on dystocia and its impacts on the health and productivity of dairy herds. Research driven by this data can lead to new strategies and technologies to reduce dystocia rates.
  4. Herd health: By sharing dystocia data, farmers contribute to the overall health and well-being of the dairy industry's herds. Understanding trends in dystocia can help identify risk factors and develop strategies to prevent difficult births, reducing the risk to cows and calves.
  5. Education and training: The CDCB and other organizations use this data to provide resources and training to dairy farmers, helping them manage dystocia more effectively in their own herds.

In short, while sharing dystocia data does take time and effort, it contributes to the improvement of the dairy industry as a whole, which can ultimately benefit individual farmers as well.


Navigating calving difficulty is a significant part of managing a successful dairy operation. Understanding and monitoring the many factors that contribute to calving ease can lead to improved herd health, more informed breeding decisions, and a more profitable farming enterprise.

By recording both calving ease and detailed dystocia data, farmers gain invaluable insights into the well-being of their herds. These insights can inform interventions and preventive measures, contributing to the health and longevity of both cows and calves. The utilization of tools like DHI-Plus software streamlines this data collection process, making it more efficient and precise.

Moreover, by sharing dystocia data with organizations such as the CDCB, farmers contribute not only to the success of their own herds but also to the broader dairy industry. This collective effort drives research and development, sets industry benchmarks, and promotes the overall genetic improvement of cattle breeds.

As we delve deeper into understanding calving difficulty, it's clear that this element of dairy farming isn't just about ensuring a successful birth - it's about shaping the future of the dairy industry. By focusing on calving difficulty, we contribute to a more sustainable and prosperous future for all dairy farmers.